Hello again! It is time for another blog post! This time I am not going to blog about something that I have learned on the job (although I did learn a lot that I could use doing my job), instead I am going to blog about a little hobby project I did.

I am a bit of a gadget-freak. I think every geek will recognize this somewhat. A little while ago I ran out of new gadgets, so I decided to buy an IP Camera. These are really cool camera’s, because they can be connected to an TCP/IP network and usually provide an http api to control the camera en read images from it. The camera I bought is a FOSCAM I8910W, although the brand is not that important. I believe that the http api’s may differ per brand, but once you know how to get an image stream, they mostly work the same.

After a bit of searching on the internet, I came across the following foscam developer pdf: http://www.foscam.es/descarga/ipcam_cgi_sdk.pdf. This pdf tells me the different url’s and parameters to make a camera pan, and it tells me that the url to capture an snapshot is something like http://<cameraadress>/snapshot.cgi with optional parameters for an usename and password. This means that when I browse to that url with an IP Camera in my network my browser will show me an image.


With this information we can basically create a video stream. We could use this url to read images in a loop and display them to the user. This method is really simple and it allows the client application to control the refresh rate. The disadvantage is that we have to send and receive a lot of http requests and those will cause a lot of overhead. So browsing a little further in our developer pdf I came across the following api.


This tells me that there is a way to do one http request and get an imagestream back! This is really what we want. As you can see there are also parameters for resolution and the rate in which the camera sends us back images. For a video of 640 * 480 at 30 fps (my max rate ) we would use the url http://<cameraadress>/videostream.cgi?resolution=32&rate=0.

The only problem is, in which format do we get our response? Well after a bit of research and monitoring with fiddler I came to the conclusion that a lot of IP Camera’s use the same format. It is called a MJPEG (Motion JPEG) stream. Wikipedia has a great article about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motion_JPEG. After reading this you realize it is quite simple! MJPEG over http is really an http multi part response where each part is an image. According to the spec http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc1341/7_2_Multipart.html the http response will look something like this (it is just http multi part, only the parts are images):


You can see, the body the of the http response will contain: one or more partheaders –> part data –> boundary->nextpartheaders –>part data –> boundary and this repeats. When I ask a video stream from my camera it will repeat endlessly.  Every header is separated by a carriage return character followed by a linefeed character. The part data is seperated from the part headers by cr lf cr lf. Normally one would read the body of the httpstream till boundary, parse the headers, read the part data till boundary, and repeat this in a loop. This means you would need to check constantly for the the boundary when you are reading the part’s body. Luckily, my camera provides the length of each part in a Content-Length part header. So my algorithm becomes clear:

-Look for the Content-Length header
-Read the length of the image from the header
-Read exactly the amount of bytes specified in the header from the part’s body data.
-Construct image from data
-Repeat this in a loop.

We can use this to write some .Net code Glimlach. The first class I have defined is a MultiPartStream class. This class represents a MultiPartStream and has methods like NextPart() which returns the bytes that belong to the next part in the stream. It has no notion of images, it is just an object oriented multi part stream. Here is the code:

   1: public class MultiPartStream

   2:     {

   3:         //Specs say that the body of each part and it's header are seperated by two crlf's

   4:         private byte[] _seperatorBytes = Encoding.UTF8.GetBytes("\r\n\r\n");

   5:         private byte[] _headerbytes = new byte[100];

   6:         private Regex _contRegex = new Regex("Content-Length: (?<length>[0-9]+)\r\n", RegexOptions.Compiled | RegexOptions.IgnoreCase);

   7:         private BinaryReader _reader;



  10:         public MultiPartStream(Stream multipartStream)

  11:         {

  12:             _reader = new BinaryReader(new BufferedStream(multipartStream));

  13:         }


  15:         private int GetPartLength(string headerSection)

  16:         {

  17:             Match m = _contRegex.Match(headerSection);

  18:             return int.Parse(m.Groups["length"].Value);

  19:         }


  21:         private bool SeperatorBytesExistsInArray(int position, byte[] array)

  22:         {

  23:             bool result = false;

  24:             for (int i = position, j = 0; j < _seperatorBytes.Length; i++, j++)

  25:             {

  26:                 result = array[i] == _seperatorBytes[j];

  27:                 if (!result)

  28:                 {

  29:                     break;

  30:                 }

  31:             }

  32:             return result;

  33:         }


  35:         private string ReadContentHeaderSection(BinaryReader stream)

  36:         {

  37:             // headers and content in multi part are seperated by two \r\n

  38:             bool found = false;


  40:             int count = 4;

  41:             stream.Read(_headerbytes, 0, 4);

  42:             for (int i = 0; i < _headerbytes.Length; i++)

  43:             {

  44:                 found = SeperatorBytesExistsInArray(i, _headerbytes);

  45:                 if (!found)

  46:                 {


  48:                     _headerbytes[count] = stream.ReadByte();

  49:                     count++;

  50:                 }

  51:                 else

  52:                 {

  53:                     break;

  54:                 }


  56:             }

  57:             return Encoding.UTF8.GetString(_headerbytes, 0, count);

  58:         }




  62:       public Task<byte[]> NextPartAsync()

  63:         {

  64:             return Task.Run(() =>

  65:                {

  66:                    // every part has it's own headers

  67:                    string headerSection = ReadContentHeaderSection(_reader);

  68:                    // let's parse the header section for the content-length

  69:                    int length = GetPartLength(headerSection);

  70:                    // now let's get the image

  71:                    return _reader.ReadBytes(length);

  72:                });

  73:         }


  75:      public void Close()

  76:       {

  77:           _reader.Dispose();

  78:       }

  79:     }

On line 4 till 7 you can see the private fields. First are the cr lf cr lf bytes that separate the headers of a part from the body of part. Then there are headerBytes. This is a buffer of 100 bytes in which I continually read a portion of a part to look for the cr lf cr lf bytes. If see these bytes, that means, the buffer contains the header of a part and I can use that header to extract the parts length. The regex on line 6 is used to parse the header and extract the lengh. Maybe some knows a better way to parse a string? The constructor wraps a BinaryReader around a BufferedStream, this is to minimze the number of IO reads on the underlying transport. The BinaryReader also reads and returns the number of bytes I tell it to. Reading from the stream directly sometimes doesn’t return all the bytes.

Now let’s have a look at some of the methods.It all starts on line 62. This method returns a Task that will extract the next part in the stream on a background thread. It first reads the header section by calling ReadContentHeaderSection. This method is defined on line 35 and this method is the one that fills the header bytes with bytes until it comes across the cr lf cr lf. It does this by reading one byte at a time and after each read it checks if finds the separator characters. After it finds those 4 characters, it will convert the bytes that are in the buffer to a string. From this string, I can extract the Content-Length header with a regular expression to read the rest of the part. I do this on line 15. After I get the part length, I can read the body of the part with the binary reader and return the bytes to our caller.

Next class I am going to discuss is the AutomaticMultiPartReader. This class accepts our previously defined MultiPartStream and starts reading from it in a loop. Every time it get’s a part it will throw an event containing the last part it got from our MultiPartStream. Here is the code for this class:

   1: public class AutomaticMultiPartReader

   2:    {

   3:        private MultiPartStream _mps;

   4:        private bool _reading = false;

   5:        private byte[] _currentPart;


   7:        public AutomaticMultiPartReader(MultiPartStream stream)

   8:        {

   9:            _mps = stream;

  10:        }


  12:        public event EventHandler<PartReadyEventArgs> PartReady;


  14:        protected virtual void OnPartReady()

  15:        {

  16:            if (PartReady != null)

  17:            {

  18:                PartReadyEventArgs args = new PartReadyEventArgs();

  19:                args.Part = _currentPart;

  20:                PartReady(this, args);

  21:            }

  22:        }

  23:        public async void StartProcessing()

  24:        {

  25:            _reading = true;

  26:            while (_reading)

  27:            {

  28:                _currentPart = await _mps.NextPartAsync().ConfigureAwait(false);

  29:                OnPartReady();

  30:            }

  31:        }


  33:        public void StopProcessing()

  34:        {

  35:            _mps.Close();

  36:            _reading = false;

  37:        }

  38:    }

The most interesting method is the StartProcessing method which starts on line 23. It starts a loop and then on line 28 calls asynchronous NextPartAsync method. By using the await keyword and ConfigureAwait(false) I make sure the the part get’s read without blocking the UI, and the event also get’s thrown from a background thread. This means that when I use this class from a presentation technology like wpf or winforms I will need to do some stuff to get this event back to the UI thread. I could also throw this event on the UI thread by not using ConfigureAwait, but I want my UI thread to stay as responsive as possible.

This takes us to the IpCamController class. This class is a bit UI specific, as it will contain the logic to take the PartReady event and translate it to a BitmapImage on the UI thread. This class also has the logic to move the camera etc. With a little bit of effort you could easily adjust it to also work with WinForms or Silverlight for example.  Below is it’s code.

   1: public class IpCamController

   2:     {

   3:         private string _url;

   4:         private string _videoRelative = "/videostream.cgi?resolution=32&rate=0";

   5:         private bool _panning;

   6:         private string _panningRelativeUri = "/decoder_control.cgi?command={0}";

   7:         private HttpClient _client;

   8:         private AutomaticMultiPartReader _reader;

   9:         private BitmapImage _currentFrame;



  12:         public IpCamController(string url, string username, string password)

  13:         {

  14:             _url = url;

  15:             WebRequestHandler handler = new WebRequestHandler();

  16:             handler.Credentials = new NetworkCredential(username, password);

  17:             _client = new HttpClient(handler);

  18:             _client.BaseAddress = new Uri(_url);

  19:             _client.Timeout = TimeSpan.FromMilliseconds(-1);

  20:         }


  22:         private async void SendPanCommand(int commandNumber)

  23:         {

  24:             HttpResponseMessage result;

  25:             result = await _client.GetAsync(string.Format(_panningRelativeUri, commandNumber));

  26:             result.EnsureSuccessStatusCode();

  27:         }


  29:         private void _reader_PartReady(object sender, PartReadyEventArgs e)

  30:         {

  31:             //let's get this events back on the UI thread

  32:             Stream frameStream = new MemoryStream(e.Part);

  33:             App.Current.Dispatcher.Invoke(new Action(() =>

  34:             {

  35:                 _currentFrame = new BitmapImage();

  36:                 _currentFrame.BeginInit();

  37:                 _currentFrame.StreamSource = frameStream;

  38:                 _currentFrame.EndInit();

  39:                 OnImageReady();

  40:             }));

  41:         }


  43:         protected void OnImageReady()

  44:         {

  45:             if (ImageReady != null)

  46:             {

  47:                 ImageReady(this, new ImageReadyEventArsgs() { Image = _currentFrame });

  48:             }

  49:         }


  51:         public void PanRight()

  52:         {

  53:             int command = _panning ? 5 : 4;

  54:             SendPanCommand(command);

  55:             _panning = !_panning;

  56:         }


  58:         public void PanLeft()

  59:         {

  60:             int command = _panning ? 7 : 6;

  61:             SendPanCommand(command);

  62:             _panning = !_panning;

  63:         }


  65:         public void PanDown()

  66:         {

  67:             int command = _panning ? 3 : 2;

  68:             SendPanCommand(command);

  69:             _panning = !_panning;

  70:         }


  72:         public void PanUp()

  73:         {

  74:             int command = _panning ? 1 : 0;

  75:             SendPanCommand(command);

  76:             _panning = !_panning;

  77:         }




  81:         public async void StartProcessing()

  82:         {

  83:             HttpResponseMessage resultMessage = await _client.GetAsync(_videoRelative, HttpCompletionOption.ResponseHeadersRead);

  84:             //because of the configure await the rest of this method happens on a background thread.

  85:             resultMessage.EnsureSuccessStatusCode();

  86:             // check the response type

  87:             if (!resultMessage.Content.Headers.ContentType.MediaType.Contains("multipart"))

  88:             {

  89:                 throw new ArgumentException("The camera did not return a mjpeg stream");

  90:             }

  91:             else

  92:             {

  93:                 _reader = new AutomaticMultiPartReader(new MultiPartStream(await resultMessage.Content.ReadAsStreamAsync()));

  94:                 _reader.PartReady += _reader_PartReady;

  95:                 _reader.StartProcessing();

  96:             }

  97:         }


  99:         public void StopProcessing()

 100:         {

 101:             _reader.StopProcessing();

 102:         }


 104:         public event EventHandler<ImageReadyEventArsgs> ImageReady;


 106:     }

First up is the constructor. I create a WebRequestHandlers to give the HttpClient class the credentials of the user. Most IP Cameras support Basic authentication, which means it is not really secure. We can pass credentials for Basic authentication via the NetworkCredentials class in .Net. I assign the base address so, I can use relative addresses later on for different camera commands. On line 19 I set the timeout property to infinite. This has to be done because the response of the IP Camera does not end, it keeps sending images, without this, the HttpClient would timeout because the response takes to long to arrive.

Most interesting bit happens on line 81. Here it all starts, I make a request to the camera video url, I tell the HttpClient to return as soon as the headers are received, I can use the headers to check for a multipartresponse type. If this is ok, I create a new AutomaticMultiPartReader, subscribe to it’s part ready event, and tell it to start processing. This does not block the UI thread because it mostly calls the NextPartAsync, which does it work on a background thread. On line 29 we can see our eventhandler. All it does, is wrapping the bytes of the received part in a MemoryStream and use this Stream to create a BitmapImage on the UI thread. It then throws an event to tell a subscriber that an image is ready. In WPF BitmapImages are just like controls, they need to be used by the same thread that creates them.

Now it is to look at a simple client application.


When you have all the above plumbing ready, a client is really simple. The above client basically consists of an Image control and four buttons. Below is the code.

   1: public partial class MainWindow : Window

   2:     {

   3:         private IpCamController _controller;

   4:         public MainWindow()

   5:         {

   6:             InitializeComponent();

   7:             this.Loaded += MainWindow_Loaded;

   8:             this.Closing += MainWindow_Closing;

   9:         }


  11:         void MainWindow_Closing(object sender, System.ComponentModel.CancelEventArgs e)

  12:         {

  13:             _controller.StopProcessing();

  14:         }


  16:         void MainWindow_Loaded(object sender, RoutedEventArgs e)

  17:         {


  19:             _controller = new IpCamController("http://yoururl","yourUsername","yourPassword");

  20:             _controller.ImageReady += dec_FrameReady ;

  21:             _controller.StartProcessing();


  23:         }


  25:         void dec_FrameReady(object sender,ImageReadyEventArsgs args)

  26:         {

  27:             imgStream.Source = args.Image;

  28:         }



  31:         private void btnRight_Click_1(object sender, RoutedEventArgs e)

  32:         {

  33:             _controller.PanRight();

  34:         }


  36:         private void btnLeft_Click_1(object sender, RoutedEventArgs e)

  37:         {

  38:             _controller.PanLeft();

  39:         }


  41:         private void btnDown_Click_1(object sender, RoutedEventArgs e)

  42:         {

  43:             _controller.PanDown();

  44:         }


  46:         private void btnUp_Click_1(object sender, RoutedEventArgs e)

  47:         {

  48:             _controller.PanUp();

  49:         }



  52:     }

  53: }

In the loading event I create a new IPCamController, I pass it an url and my credentials. I subscribe to it’s ImageReady event and in that event I just assign a new Image to the Image control. That’s it! All the pan methods are simple and are easily explained with the developer pdf. There is still a lot to improve in this app. I could make use of the MVVM pattern for example, but for learning and demo purposes this will do. Also keep in mind that this MultiPart parser will only work if a camera also provides a Content-Length header per part, if a camera doesn’t, we need to keep reading each part until we come across the boundary. So this little demo app still has plenty of things to do to make it more robust.

That’s it for today! I hope you get inspired by this blog post to try some of these things for yourself to learn even more. Feel free to leave comments and suggestions.!


6 thoughts on “Writing an IP Camera Viewer in C# 5.0

  1. Nice work! Although a mobile app would make much more sense. If the camera is supported by a NAS (eg: Synology), you may not need your own app.

    • I am planning to port this C# code to WinRT in the future for a mobile app. This should be easily doable. The same goes for Windows Phone. I have a Windows 8 tablet at home and I can use this app straight from my tablet (it’s x86 architecture). If had made it a Windows Store App, I would need to through the Windows Store to do this.

      My camera actually is supported by my Synology Nas, but I really found Surveillance Station from Synology not that great performance wise. Choppy video streams etc. Especially on my tablet, where I have to use it via a browser. I don’t like to brag, but my app does perform fast:).

  2. hello..how are you…thank you for your nice code
    I need your help …I can not view image from my IP camera wih your code (I set the URL and username and password)
    the model of my IP camera is panasonic/BL-C111CE..
    help me please:(

    • Hi there,

      Unfortunately I can not tell you specifically where this goes wrong as I don’t have your camera model. I can not view the response or error. If you could tell me what goes wrong I could be of more help. If I have to make a guess I would say that it has to with the length of each image part in the response. Not all cameras communicate this length. This would mean that you would have to read the resposne, seperating the parts based on a seperator sequence of characters.

      • hi Chris van Beek
        thank you for your answer :)
        I think my problem is in my URL
        in firefox the url that show my cameras images is (
        when I set the code’s url to and run it,the error is

        An unhandled exception of type ‘System.ArgumentException’ occurred in mscorlib.dll
        Additional information: The camera did not return a mjpeg stream

        then i changed the _videoRelative = “/videostream.cgi?resolution=32&rate=0″ to _videoRelative = “/CgiStart?page=Single&Language=0″
        again the above error occured

        also when I enter my firefox url in this mode http:///videostream.cgi?resolution=32&rate=0 ..it can not find the request URL …
        should I enter the port of my camera in the url ?

        • What do you mean with the port? Isn’t your camera running on port 80? If it isn’t than you should enter the port. If it is, I think your camera might actually not send back a mjpegstream. Maybe there is some developer information about your camera available? Maybe it has a specific uri for mjpeg. I think this is only fixable if there is some documentation available..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>